Saturday, January 22, 2011

Rahul Gandhi spoke for one Kalavathy but, who will speak for Maheswari?

Kannaiyan

One morning in December, my neighbour informed me that a farmer had been trampled to death by elephants, in Madhahally, a short distance from my own Thalavady. On the edge of Sathyamangalam Reserve Forest, a home for tiger, elephant, wild boar, gaurs and deer, it is not uncommon for wild animals to stray into adjoining villages. Typically, farmers keep a look out for wild animals and warn others.  However, twenty five year old Kumar was not so lucky, he was trampled to death by some elephants even as he stepped out of his thatched house. On his way to his maize field to guard it from wild animals, he did not notice in the darkness, some elephants standing just outside, he did not have a moment to alert the others or save himself.
Thousands of people gathered in Madhahally, and I was there as well. People were very upset and angry about the death of a young lad, and stood about debating how to prevent such incidents, decrying forest department officials who were lax in helping the farmers to drive the back wild elephants who strayed out of the Reserve Forest.   A group of farmers were angry that no forest official had come to the spot, and refused to allow the police to take Kumar’s body. “It is the responsibility of the forest officials to protect us from wild animals” said a farmer. “Who will take care of his young wife and children,” wailed an elderly woman.  I was finally able to convince the group to allow the police to take the body to Primary Health Centre for post-mortem.  Finally a young forest official, Ashok came to Madhahally and in my presence gave a cheque of Rs. 25000 as accident relief to Kumar’s 23 year old wife, Maheswari. He confirmed that the Forest Department gave up to Rs. 150,000 as compensation to the family of a victim killed by a wild animal.
 I visited Maheswari on January 21st, just after Pongal, the annual harvest festival. Talking to her, I learnt that she had yet not received the balance compensation. Of the Rs. 25000 she got, she gave 10000 rupees to her maternal uncle to conduct the formalities and paper work. Her uncle had to go  at primary health centre, police station, meet revenue department officials  to get the death certificate and post-mortem certificate. She still required the “legal heir” certificate without which she could not make an application for the remaining compensation due from the Forest department. 
Maheswari with her younger girl baby  Shivamallugamma.
Talking to Maheswari, I understood that Kumar had recently bought plough-bullocks by getting loan from a self-help group of which he was a member. She showed me her bank pass-book and explained, “from the 25000 rupees, I repaid this SHG loan of 7000 and another 7000 rupees to my neighbour. My husband had borrowed as a short term loan for the maize crop. The rest gave to my uncle for the formalities.   The maize crop has been destroyed by the straying animals as I was in no shape to save it”.   Kumar’s pass book showed a loan balance of Rs.32, 200, and apart from this, Maheswari said they had borrowed 11,000 rupees by mortgaging her jewellery at the local Primary Agricultural Cooperative Credit Society, together with interest it amounted to nearly 50000 rupees. She said, that Kumar leased two acres of rain fed land from neighbour and cultivated maize.   But, the crop too had been mostly been destroyed by straying wild boars and elephants after Kumar’s death.
 I felt helpless, as I talked to the 23 year old Maheswari. With tears she could not control, holding her infant child in her arms, she said, “the elephants took the life of my dear husband, leaving me land less and homeless. I speak Kannada and know only a smattering of Tamil. I do not know the government offices. Who will speak for me? Who will help me to build my small children’s future?” No forest official or elected representative came to support Maheswari.  She stands beside her thatched hut, with no idea how she will support herself. 
 As I say good bye, Maheswari pleads with me, “Anna, please come again. Will you ask the forest department to give me the remaining money so I can repay the loans?”  Who will speak for the dead farmer’s wife, Maheswari.   I drive back to my village, I could not help wondering how the young farmer’s widow, who had her whole life ahead would manage. Maheswari was just 23, had two little children, and like any village girl had no education or training. The compensation of Rs.150, 000 would not go very far, I thought to myself. Maheswari has no clue when she will get the legal heir certificate and how much money still she needs to complete the formalities….
  Who is responsible for protecting farmers and their crops? Does the meagre compensation divest the government from its larger responsibility to the farming community? Can we expect farmers to save wild animals, when we have no policy to protect them and their families?  

Maheswari With her two girl children
Shanthamallamma and Shivamallugamma.
With no one to help farmers to protect themselves and their crops from wild animals, farmers are virtually at the mercy of a parasitic bureaucracy and indifferent politicians…. Can throwing small money at people help to rebuild their lives?  A thought crosses my mind, “Rahul Gandhi spoke for one Kalavathy, but who will speak for Maheswari?”

2 comments:

RAJAN ILANGOVAN said...

DEAR kANNAIAN,
I have worked in thalavady and madahalli area some ten years ago.
It is a pathetic situation that young widow with two female childrens face the problem. I often say that you can trust politicians some time but the officials are more correuptive . It is a government money being given to affected persons. From that money they need cuttings......
what a beautiful independance India.

macmohan said...

This is the story of many villagers living in the forest fringes and inside forests. The dangers of coming into conflict with wildlife has risen many times than in the past. Wild animals come into villages, like we humans go into forests. It is always better to keep distance from wild elephants to avoid such incidents.

Wild animals has home range that may be the nearby villages also. It is important we find their home range before using the word "stray".

Elephants don't jointly trample a single man, an elephant can trample. We need to understand the elephant behavior, home range also here.

Every loss of human life leaves a permanent deep psychological scars in the family. It becomes worse if it happens to be breadwinner like Kumar. I appreciate you have spoken for his wife Maheshwari and her children. Money alone cannot compensate the huge loss she is suffering.

Farmers who live in the forests and forest fringes carry a huge responsibility in protecting wild animals. There is a huge amount of risk involved to the people and I agree there is no government policy in place except compensation money. Many people living in conflict areas know these risk factors and choose to live there, even though alternative livelihood options exist outside. Known devil is better than unknown angel.